I’m currently working on reviewing a book which outlines the history of Catholicism in America. Certainly no light task (the book, not the review). As I plow through the 400 or so pages in this book, I continue to reflect on the nature of history…what exactly are we claiming to do when we do history? What is good history? What is bad history? In my own field, New Testament, the question is equally valid although somewhat more difficult to answer. As time passes, and events become more remote, determining “what actually happened” becomes more and more difficult. I might even go so far as to claim that figuring out “what actually happened” is actually impossible. When reconstructing an event, a movement, the context behind a text, etc., the historian is painting a landscape by looking through a relatively narrow window. There are times when the window can become larger, and perhaps the historian may even stick her head out for a look now and again, but when returning to the canvas there is only so much that can be painted. Some have better grasps on history than others, but the fact remains that history is far too complex to ever be completely accurate.
Now, you might be wondering about the title of this post? Well, it involves a story that dates back to the year 2002, at the homecoming parade of my alma mater, Southern Methodist University. It is a story of history gone awry, of a group of persons who were doing a sort of history but failing at every turn.
In this homecoming parade, as with many parades, there were floats. A certain fraternity (that will remain nameless to avoid embarassing those who built the float), constructed a monstrosity that will forever be burned in my memory. The float had a giant space shuttle, flanked on both sides with Apollo and Mercury rockets. Any free space was filled with American flags. On the front of this float, in bright, bold letters, was the statement, “United States — First in Space.”
I approached the president of the fraternity (who I later found out birthed the idea) and asked him about the float. Specifically, I wanted to know whether it was a joke. He looked at me and said, “No, its no joke.” He raised an eyebrow at me, as if to say, “What are you talking about, stupid…don’t you know your history?” I informed him as charitably as I could that America was not first in space. Hadn’t he heard of Sputnik? Panic overtook him, followed by a grin and the statement, “Yes, but we put the first people into space.” I shook my head and said, “Haven’t you heard of Yuri Gagarin?” He replied, “Nope, I haven’t.” And with that he continued his walk.
History is written by those who have chosen to synthesize the facts, and their product can only be called an interpretation. Sometimes, ignorance of the obvious can have terrible, embarrasing consequences, like the aforementioned homecoming float. Other times, ignorance of the nuanced can produce equally interesting (and strange) results.





